No Rapture on 9/23/17? But Prophecy is Both Signs AND Time (Consider: the Metonic Cycle)

Phyllis Beveridge Nissila (commentary)

Claire Beveridge Gumbs (prophecy charts)

In the fullness of time…

If you were perhaps thinking that on September 23, 2017 the Rapture was supposed to occur, as some thought, but now it’s the 24th or later, you are likely both disappointed and discouraged. I mean, according to some prophecy watchers, those recent signs in the constellations were pretty convincing, right?! (See here for an example discussion.)

You might even be a touch cynical by now,  tending to agree with those referenced in 2 Peter 3:4 who said, “Where is this ‘coming’ he promised? Ever since our ancestors died, everything goes on as it has since the beginning of creation.”

Got it.

But please remember: as the epigraph connotes: it is not only signs but also time that factor into prophecy.

Using my new favorite metaphor for God’s Word and His interactions with His creation, the Antikythera mechanism* (the ancient calculator comprised of multiple linking gears and levers that helped people determine many cosmic and other, time-specific events), I see signs and time  as two gears in God’s prophetic calculator, if you will,  that, synced up, help us to know more precisely what to expect.

But what about “(no) one knows the day or hour when these things will happen (the Lord’s return–in the “twinkling of an eye“), not even the angels in heaven or the Son himself. Only the Father knows” (Matthew 24:36, NLT)?

This Scripture, weighty due to its utterance by Jesus, Himself, does give pause to attempt to set a possible date and for more reasons than just His warning.

For instance, with regard to the minute measurement of an “eye twinkle” that some believe to be what’s called “Planck time“–the smallest amount possible– we are literally hardly conscious of that minute amount of time let alone able to predict it.

For another, regarding the larger time allocations of days and hours, prophecy scholars point to the return of Jesus to “harpazo” (“snatch away” ) His bride as most likely to occur at some moment during the over-two-day Feast of Trumpets where the exact appearance of the new moon could be any time within the late hours of one day or the early hours of the next.

For yet another closely related to the previous one, many scholars point to how major prophecies relate closely with the Jewish feasts and the ones left to be fulfilled are all in the fall season. Here is a chart with this information clearly presented.

And then there are the various interpretive traditions regarding the Rapture ranging from the notion that it was an idea invented in the nineteenth century to the notion, on the other end of the interpretive spectrum, of  “Pan-Tribulation,” or, everything will just “pan out” in the end as a lighter-side reference to how mankind will somehow just work it all out.

BUT what I think is perhaps the greatest challenge is the prophecy-comprehension-challenging event of the changing of time measurement to solar and luni-solar calendars versus the original, lunar calendar, “God’s original calendar,” as it were.

I mean, if one’s prophesy predictions are based on one  kind of calendar but over time that time measurement is changed, how easy would it be to not only get the “time” of His appearing wrong but in all the confusion how easy would it be to then just focus only on the “signs” which are much easier to notice–and, it has to be said, to fool millions (sometimes on purpose)?

So how’s a serious prophesy student to make sense of time-sensitive events if the calendar got hacked?

Researchers might have found a way. A way hidden, perhaps, both in the dusty tomes of eras past and obscure modern scientific texts; in meeting minutes of by-gone religious councils, convocations, and committees who met (often in secret) to decide such things from their viewpoint; and/or in complex charts and graphs with calculations beyond the math levels of most of humanity.

But with God, you know, any seeker can find


I think one such help exists in the little known work of  Greek astronomer Meton  of Athens who calculated what is referred to as the Metonic Cycle  (5th century B.C.). The cycle, when synced up with the Jewish Feasts and other historical data compiled elsewhere concerning what prophecies have already been fulfilled and what remain, opens up much greater understanding of our times.

For prophecy watchers, crucial understanding.

Among other purposes, the Metonic Cycle allows researchers to see specifically when the solar calendar and the lunar calendar sync up which, as it just so happens,  tend also to be times, as noted in other references, when events of prophetic significance for Jews have occurred and many believe, will occur–not only prophetic events involving Jews, but Christians and mankind at large.

(Note: at this point people who, for one reason or another, believe God switched His allegiance from Jew to Christian at the turning of the Testaments will experience some serious cognitive dissonance, but please read on and allow yourself to be challenged.)

Thus, I think it is important to consider the significance of the Metonic Cycle as a key element of prophecy because whereas many similar “signs” such as the so-called Revelation chapter 12 constellation that just occurred have occurred before,  this one could have simply been another such sign in a series, a shadow of the real and time-precise event. And, much more importantly, if prophecy watchers focus only on signs, they are at great risk of being led–and fooled–by signs alone.

Consider how our real enemy can very convincingly counterfeit all manner of signs and wonders in the sky as well as on land. BUT, please note, Satan cannot control time. And even though there were those who changed how time is calculated, He Who knows the end from the beginning knew that would happen, too.

You might say that when God established the lunar calendar, as it is now known, as the way to chart days and months and years (and Jewish feasts established on that calendar), He already knew about the hackers.

And He Who is in ultimate charge of orbits and constellation movements and other cosmic wonders as well as correlating events on land had, in the design of His calculating mechanism, as it were, geared it so that certain signs occurred on certain dates when–wait for it–the various calendars  (solar and lunar in particular) aligned with His original plan.


–“Unto us a child is born (in the fullness of time*”),”

–Jesus was raised from the dead as “the first fruits of those who have fallen asleep,” on precisely, the Feast of First Fruits according to the Jewish (lunar) calendar of the year He was crucified. (To see a chart detailing how other key prophetic events align with Jewish Feasts, click here), and for just one modern-day event,

Israel will be reborn in one day (see also  how that ancient prophecy was fulfilled, literally, on May 14, 1948). (Even in modern times, centuries after the councils, convocations, and committees finished tweaking the calendar according to their ideas, prophesies continue to click with the original as designed in the very first convocation of Three at the juncture when eternity synchronized with time, you know, in the beginning.)

And that’s not all.

Within the precise natural and supernatural mechanisms of God’s calculation device that has been, and will continue to be, aligning and clicking fulfillment through time (and space and feasts and worldwide events) despite mankind’s efforts to obfuscate the plan of salvation (whether our efforts are unintended or intended–see here , for example, for a prophecy way back when about what the future Anti-Christ will be up to with regard to time) there are other gears slowly synchronizing with God’s will, plan, and ultimate redemption of all who place their trust in Him.

For example, see here  for a charted view of a “gear” called “The Model of Three Then Four” that gives a brief background for how the Metonic Cycle factors in, then here  for  more specifics on Meton’s ancient, brilliant device that helps prophecy watchers now, particularly now, as many Christians are temped to run hither and yon following this or that sign and/or wonder, spending money, time, and emotions trying to comprehend what it all might mean.

After all, aren’t we supposed to have a heads-up about things to come–and not some random, anti- or extra-biblical, bizzaro “things to come,” but the real McCoys?

Meanwhile, it has to be said, many pastors are leading their flocks in other directions altogether in the quest for “a richer life now,” or some manner of (emotion-grabbing and collection-plate-filling) “gold dust and feathers” phenomena, and/or weeping statues, stigmata-pierced “holy people,” and/or  New Gospels that filter out the hard stuff (like repentance and Hell and those deemed “non-seeker-friendly” messages).***

So some suggest, and I concur, that in order for the two “gears” of signs AND time to sync up, it has to be the right “signs at the right time.

Some students of prophecy are slowly beginning to understand that the Metonic Cycle needs to enter the prophecy discussion, and given the signs of the times that even non-believers have a hunch might be biblical in proportion, the discussions need to commence and continue.


Now, even.

So that not only will believers who are sincerely trying to understand prophecy cease to be discouraged by yet more questionable date/event setters but we will also remain hopeful and, most importantly, continue to “occupy” in each of our specific “ministries” as time ticks–and gears click–closer to that “blessed hope“.

And so that we will better understand just how imminent the Rapture is–along with other prophesied events of end times even now unfolding.

Peruse the linked articles, charts, and video below, and see what you think.


*A mechanical computation of The Metonic Cycle is just one of the computations featured on the Antikythera Mechanism.

**I like the poetry of this nuance of the definition of “time” from the same reference, above, not to mention its metaphorical reference to Jesus Christ: “the time since the star began to shine.” Lovely.

***See here for my sister Claire and my experiences trying to find a Church in our area still adhering to the core tenets of Christianity and how many trinkets, idols, and false teachings we had to wade through. It’s likely the same, these days, in your area. Stay in the Word of God, my friends, with discernment, careful study, and prayers for guidance prior.

May I recommend, for much, much more information on all that is contained in the book of Revelation (time, history, symbolism, metaphor, physics, math, and so on) Chuck Missler’s 24 CD series on this book. The series can be purchased, or viewed on his series of You Tube videos, starting here:

This entry was posted in Commentaries, encouragement in hard times, Metonic cycle, most recent posts, prophecy, prophecy puzzle pieces and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to No Rapture on 9/23/17? But Prophecy is Both Signs AND Time (Consider: the Metonic Cycle)

  1. Hi Phyllis,

    I arrived at this post as per your link given to me in an earlier comment.
    I see that you like to go into depth and detail on this subject – that is all way beyond me. I think that is why I felt it best for me personally, not to get into this level of complexity.

    However, my main reason for commenting here is to say that a little while back, when I was following another blogger, she gave info on C Missler that was rather alarming. As her blog went private I can only suggest that you do a search on “Chuck Missler Exposed”. However, I guess you may already be aware of his links with the UN and such dealings. Anyway, I don’t follow his stuff. I have in the past, had sooo many books etc from so many “false teachers” that I go with much more caution nowadays.

    Hope you don’t mind me saying this. We’re all on a learning path and we all find out things at differing rates.

    Blessings to you,


    • pbn says:

      Hi, Helen,

      Yes, I am aware of the late Chuck Missler’s reputation in certain aspects of his life. I value his life-long work, however, in different areas of what he shares related to physics, history, languages, old and new testament prophecies, linguistics, quantum mechanics, and so on, as well as respecting his associates in the area of Biblical prophecy. I also value his research into how the prophecies in the Old Testament are revealed in the New.

      I completely agree that we have to continue being wary. I tell ya, what we found out in our odyssey in some places would make the hair stand up on your neck! It reminded us of when the Spirit of the Lord gave Ezekiel quick “glimpses” of the corruption that was taking place in the temple walls…. Each scene as shocking as the previous.

      And, of course, there is little more sensational and attention-getting than end times prophecy. Consider all the false predictions, for one thing. And consider the amount of money than can be made by both conjectured accounts and fictional accounts of what might happen and when it might happen, It’s hard to sometimes know who is a true prophet and who is in it profit,

      There are a couple of famous, currently popular prophecy teachers who are making a killing on their predictions which seem quite well researched. I’m not an expert, even with a forty-year interest in the subject, but if somebody is doing an infomercial for a book as their prophecy presentation, it’s a huge red flag for me.

      And, of course, there is a lot of dust stirred up over pre, mid, and/or post Tribulation Rapture theories, I don’t mind who believes what, but I usually hold my peace when the anti-pre-Tribs get going. In my experience, they seem to be angry.

      That said, there is a blessing attached to reading the major book of prophecy, Revelation (1:3) so it’s good to study, however, of course, not essential for salvation.

      Blessings and cheers,


  2. Pingback: “Where the Rubber Meets the Road…Jesus Christ”: On Reality–and Encouragement | pnissila

  3. Carl Gordon says:

    Wow! You nailed it! Let’s talk! One idea, in the section you mention about the changing of calendars (just before the first century – the introduction of the Julian calendar) perhaps a link to this Daniel 7:25 reference: Daniel 7:25Young’s Literal Translation (YLT)

    25 and words as an adversary of the Most High it doth speak, and the saints of the Most High it doth wear out, and it hopeth to change seasons and law; and they are given into its hand, till a time, and times, and a division of a time.

    Those words, “division of time…” are sooooo important to give people understanding right now!

    Well done!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.